90% familiar, 10% novel
Make most of it familiar so the one odd part reads as chosen.
Rauno Freibergrauno.meNovelty is the equivalent of an exclamation mark. Akin to seasoning, you don't want too much of it.
Rauno Freibergrauno.meFor software design, I could see a similar framework making sense: make 90% of the experience familiar, and 10% novel.
Both cards use the same eight parts; only how many are novel changes.
1 · Turn up the novelty
Drag the slider and watch the left card.
Everything shoutsBad
6 of 8 parts novelOne exclamation markGood
1 of 8 parts novel/* 90%: the system look */
.input, .toggle, .card { font: inherit; border-radius: var(--radius); }
/* 10%: one part is allowed to be odd */
.btn-primary { background: linear-gradient(135deg, var(--a), var(--b)); }
Why it matters, pros and cons
Why it matters
A settings screen is read hundreds of times. Odd parts compete, so only one should.
Pros
- People already know how the familiar parts work.
- The odd part is the one thing they look at.
- Brand shows up without slowing anyone down.
Cons
- Familiar everywhere can feel generic.
- Which 10% to spend is a judgment call.
- Marketing pages can afford a higher ratio.